CHRISTOPHER RHINELANDER ROBERT II

 

He was the grandson of Doctor Daniel Robert, and born to Christopher R. Robert, a millionaire importer in 1835. For most of his very privileged life he socialized with The Vanderbilts, Cuttings, Astors etc in New York, Paris, Newport, Rhode Island and out on Oakdale, LI , where he had a country gentlemans estate known as "Pepperidge Hall". He also inherited his fathers share of "Doctors Point" in Mastic in 1878. He most likely spent some time there duck hunting because his name appears as the estate owner on several maps from the 1870's on through the early 1900's along with his nephew Chas. S Robert. I think Christopher definitely left his mark in Mastic..... Being a wealthy builder, he most likely is the one who had constructed the finer Victorian buildings on the estate that were not in the style of the buildings his farmer cousins the W. S. Robert clan would of used. Some examples were the Victorian carriage houses,like the late Red Barn Restaurant constructed at a cost of $7,000.00!! and current Mowdy homes on Cranberry & Diana Dr another former carriage house are examples) and other outbuildings like the Messinetti outhouse/toolshed on Bayview Drive

His life (that was reported in the papers) seems to have been a series of odd occurrences ...he reportedly had quite a rivalry going with his neighbor William K. Vanderbilt (read the hunting dog incident) in Oakdale and I read of some derricks that were blocking access to his Riverside Drive apartment . He wound up suing the mayor of NY city and the construction equipment wound up in the Hudson River during the night.... but what I found most interesting about Christopher Rhinelander Robert was .....

the mystery of how he died.

 

Being that he had sold (traded actually) Pepperidge Hall his Oakdale Estate by 1896 , the "someplace in Long Island his family went to"

after his death was most likely Doctors Point in Mastic.

 

The initial report in the New York Daily Tribune was word for word with the Times. This follow up offers a few variations and a few errors . For example it says Mrs. Robert went to their Oakdale Estate. He traded that place off in November of 1896

 

 

SO WHAT DO YOU THINK?...... DID HE OR DIDN'T HE?

Here is what Newsday a current Long Island daily paper

has about it on their

L. I. OUR STORY WEBSITE

 

In 1866, as the railroad reached the area, Liff's wealthy patrons formed the Southside Sportsmen's Club, and soon the race was on to see who could create the most superb spread in the thick forests adjoining Great South Bay. The most prominent were William K. Vanderbilt, grandson of railroad magnate Cornelius Vanderbilt; Frederick G. Bourne, president of the Singer Sewing Machine Co., and Christopher Robert II, an eccentric heir to a sugar fortune. By 1888, Robert built a spectacular castle just east of Idle Hour called Pepperidge Hall, magnificently furnished in the French style for his young wife. But the pair didn't get along. On Jan. 2, 1898, she told police she found Robert shot to death in his Manhattan apartment. It was ruled suicide and she moved to Paris.

 

HAS THE JURY REACHED A DECISION?

We Have Your Honor .......

 

 

I think that if a detective like Columbo was around back then, Julia Remington Morgan Robert, the pretty woman, now twice a widow, may of had to answer a few more questions.
Another piece of possible irony is I am reasonably sure that Dr. Charles S. Robert was at one time a NY City coroner !! however I believe he was already dead at this time and if he were living then I have no idea what type of relationship he had with his Uncle Christopher.

 

I know there was a contest to Christopher's will , as it was made out just about a month before he died leaving most everything to Julia. Reports on what he was worth vary from 1 million to 30 ! I know that for several future court suits against her after 1900 the widow Robert did not show up ....... and to think that the little sleepy hamlet that would become the center of Mastic Beach some 28 years later, played a small part in this big high society who dunnit.

 

NOW TAKE A LOOK AT THE C. R. ROBERT
PLACE JUST DOWN THE ROAD IN OAKDALE

Presenting

PEPPERIDGE HALL

aka

PEPPERIDGE FARM

(no kidding it really was)